Introducing Customer Efficacy, a Replacement for Customer Success
Customer Success (CS) started as the right idea. Somewhere along the way, greed and technology corrupted it. After a decade of arguing over how to repair it, I believe the better path is to tear it out and replace it.
This month Bain published a blueprint for rebuilding Customer Success. Its numbers explain why: headcount has grown more than 50% in six years, while median net revenue retention at public software companies has fallen from about 115% to about 107%. On November 12, Gainsight cut a reported 270 jobs and announced it was rebuilding itself around a similar model.
Bain says the owner’s skills and pay should look like an account executive’s. That is an account manager with a new title and a belief that AI will handle the rest. Bain would measure that owner on adoption, usage, advocacy, and consumption, and every one of those is the vendor’s measure. Nothing in either one is new.
Joel Passen, the CEO of Solid, shared a similar opinion: “Read between the lines and the accountable human is an account manager.” He argues the function is being dissolved, with commercial work going to account management, technical work to specialists, and the long tail to AI agents.
By the time the industry’s “experts” finish solving this problem, no one will be left standing on the customer’s side.
Customer Success Has a Conflict of Interest
Customer Success was created to fix a revenue problem. Subscription customers could leave, and companies needed them to stay. But it didn’t start as a quota-carrying job. The first Customer Success team, at Vantive in 1996, met customers before the contract was signed and agreed with them on what success would look like. For most of the years since, the people doing the work were measured on retention and adoption. The sales number came later. At Google, where CS was a cost center, I remember the first talk of renewal and revenue expectations around 2022, mostly to justify the team’s existence. Today, 83% of Customer Success managers own revenue in some form, whether a formal quota, a shared target, or an informal expectation, according to ChurnZero’s 2026 survey.
Every company cares about revenue, and that won’t change. A company is trying to sell a product to a customer. There is always an agenda, and customers know it.
My problem has always been where the loyalty goes. Once a quota is attached, the work shifts away from the customer, whether the team wants it to or not. I’ve said it before: if Customer Success were about generating revenue, we’d call it Sales Success. The quota creates a conflict of interest, and the success being measured stops being the customer’s.
Where Else Customer Success is Failing
Customer Success describes itself as proactive. In practice, most teams meet the customer after the contract is signed, through a handoff from sales. By then, the sales process has set the goals, and the team’s first real task is to protect a deal it had no part in shaping. Plenty of talk focuses on being proactive, but the practice is reactive.
Customers notice. In Bain’s 2024 survey, nearly two-thirds of software customers said their post-sales needs were only moderately addressed or worse. In the same survey, net revenue retention had declined at 75% of software companies, even as they invested more in Customer Success.
The tools show the same thing. A health score predicts whether an account will renew. A quarterly business review reports on the vendor’s product and often ends with a proposal to buy more. Both are built to answer the company’s revenue question, and neither asks the customer whether the purchase did what they needed or looks ahead to what they will need next.
Introducing Customer Efficacy
The industry’s response has been version numbers: Customer Success 2.0, 3.0, and now an AI-first edition alongside Bain’s “The Rebirth of Customer Success.” Every version keeps the same conflict.
Customer Success needs to be completely replaced with something new.
Customer Efficacy (CE) is what’s next.
Efficacy means the power to produce a desired result. Applied to a customer, it asks one thing: did this customer get the result they came to you for?
The Definition
Customer Efficacy is a business discipline and organizational function that works with customers to produce the results they value.
The customer defines the results and confirms when they are achieved. The provider brings the expertise and guidance, and the two teams work together to produce value.
Why Customer Efficacy is the answer
The theory is simple: Customers who get the result they came for will stay.
Three things change when a team is built around that premise.
- Larger deals from the start. A strategic advisor with no quota shows the customer what is possible before the contract, so the deal is scoped bigger at signing.
- Customers reach value faster. The first outcome is defined and piloted before the sale, so value shows up in weeks.
- Customers stay and grow without being sold to. The company stays aligned with what the customer values, so churn falls, and expansion gets easier.
Customers aren’t asking for much. They bought the product to get something done, and they want help from someone who will be straight with them. That’s hard to do when the person helping them is also responsible for the renewal. Customers pick up on it, and they stop listening. Customer Efficacy takes that pressure off. The advisor shows up at the first conversation, long before there’s a contract, and gets paid when the customer hits their objectives. I’ve worked this way for years. When customers get what they came for, they stay, and most of them end up buying more without anyone pushing.
What comes next
Customer Success is already being taken apart. Companies are cutting teams and folding what’s left into sales, and nobody has proposed anything that puts the customer first. Customer Efficacy is my answer.
It isn’t finished. I’m putting the name out now so people can poke holes in it while I’m still building it. Over the next few months, I’ll write about how to set up a Customer Efficacy team and measure it, and I’ll talk to Customer Success leaders and their customers along the way.
If you run a Customer Success team and you think it’s time for a real change, get in touch. I’d like to hear what you’re seeing.